Big Risks, Bigger Rewards: The Reality of Retail Leasing
Never miss an episode of Retail Retold.
Topics: retail real estate, shopping centers, grocery anchors, market trends, deal stories, leadership, networking, retail industry
A strong retail market is creating new opportunities, but making the right deals still takes conviction.
Retail real estate has been through its fair share of challenges, but the industry keeps proving its resilience. With limited new supply, strong tenant demand, and shopping centers evolving to serve more of consumers’ everyday needs, the opportunities for owners and operators continue to grow.
David Gerstenhaber, Senior Vice President & Head of Leasing at Brixmor Property Group, joins Chris Ressa to discuss what’s driving retail’s momentum, the realities of dealmaking, and the lessons he’s learned over 20 years in the industry.
From traditional retail to fitness, healthcare, dining, and entertainment, the shopping center tenant mix has changed dramatically. David explains how these shifts are creating stronger assets, driving traffic, and opening the door to new leasing opportunities.
But not every great deal looks great on paper.
David shares the story of a grocery deal in central New Jersey that nearly didn’t happen. Despite questionable sales projections, a divided family-owned retailer, and significant financial risk, he saw an opportunity others weren’t convinced existed. What followed was an unconventional decision-making process that ultimately turned a struggling shopping center into a major success story.
Chris and David dig into what that deal reveals about understanding a market beyond the numbers, recognizing what a community actually needs, and having the conviction to make difficult decisions.
They also discuss one of David’s biggest career challenges: transitioning from dealmaker to leader. From learning through mistakes to building a trusted network of industry peers, David shares how relationships and experience have shaped his approach to leasing and leadership.
For anyone involved in retail real estate, it’s a conversation about what separates a good opportunity from a great deal, and why the best decisions aren’t always the most obvious ones.
What You’ll Hear
- Why retail real estate continues to thrive despite decades of industry challenges
- How evolving tenant mixes and limited new supply are strengthening shopping centers
- The challenges of transitioning from dealmaker to leader and lessons learned along the way
- Why building relationships with industry peers is essential to long-term success
- How a risky grocery deal became one of Brixmor’s biggest success stories
- Why understanding local markets and looking beyond the data can make or break a deal
- The role grocery anchors play in driving traffic, supporting tenants, and creating long-term value
Chapters
00:42 — Meet David Gerstenhaber
David’s background and his 20-year career at Brixmor Property Group.
02:02 — From advertising sales to retail leasing
How David broke into commercial real estate and worked his way up to head of leasing.
04:26 — Why retail is thriving
How limited supply, healthier tenants, and evolving shopping centers are strengthening the industry.
07:33 — From dealmaker to leader
The challenges of managing a team, learning from mistakes, and developing leadership skills.
11:43 — The power of industry relationships
Why building a trusted network of peers is essential to success in retail real estate.
14:33 — The grocery deal that almost didn’t happen
How David pursued a regional grocer despite skepticism, challenging projections, and significant financial risk.
18:46 — When the numbers don’t tell the whole story
Why Brixmor’s investment committee took a hands-on approach to a risky deal that became a major success.
22:21 — Why grocery anchors matter
How grocery stores drive traffic, support surrounding tenants, and strengthen shopping centers.
25:35 — Three questions with David
Extinct retailers, recent shopping purchases, and his favorite Target aisle.
About Retail Retold:
The Retail Retold Podcast highlights community retailer stories from across the country and gives a behind-the-scenes perspective from business leaders in both retail and real estate industries. The show’s episodes contain valuable insights that help solve the needs of entrepreneurs and real estate pros. Join host Chris Ressa and new guests weekly for amazing insights and thought-provoking stories.